Kursk,
written by Robert Rodat and directed by Thomas Vinterberg
Seven out
of 10
There is much
to celebrate in a drama that tells the story of the submarine disaster that
took place in 2000 and in which the Russian leadership showed its ugly, mean,
inhuman face.
Instead of
reading this note, I would suggest that you access Variety and look at the
excellent review posted there, albeit it would make you avoid the film, given
that it is quite critical of it.
The saga of
the submarine made the headlines around the world and the callousness, cruelty
of those who lead Russia became once again evident for those who have eyes and
a minimal understanding of events.
The eternal
leftist, guerilla fighters, people like Corbyn, Maduro, Trump would agree with
anything Putin says and does, including sentencing sailors to die because they
are inept and refuse aid from the West.
The director
is the incredible Thomas Vinterberg, famous for the astonishing Festen and the
acclaimed Jagten, but the critic from Variety is right to point out the
shortcomings of this mega production.
The cast
could not include more iconic figures:
Max von Sydow
– if only for his presence in the masterpieces signed by Ingmar Bergman and he
has a place in the history of cinema, along with some other major gods – has the
role of a vile character – Vladimir Petrenko.
As one of
the leaders of the Russian Navy, he boasts and manifest a criminal arrogance after
the calamity is produced, refusing to accept the international offers of help
It must be
noted though that in spite of the fact that this is surely a villain and the
orphans are right in refusing to shake his hand when the funeral and religious
service is organized, he is one of the less relevant ones.
The Absolute
Monster is missing from this picture, alas!
Vladimir Putin
was the ultimate commander in chief and the one who would not agree to a loss
of face, the saving of his subjects with foreign vessels, an intervention that
would highlight the precarious, disastrous state of equipment, the economy,
vessels, technology – everything in other words – and would mean a humiliating
PR stunt.
Let the
sailors die, rather than admit to the truth – in the meantime, fueled by
revenues form gas, oil and other natural resources, the Russian army has seen
its budget increase and important sums of money have been spent for better
equipment, although that economy is still smaller than Italy’s and much of the noise
made is just an effort to punch above its weight.
In short,
an accident takes place on board the submarine Kursk and the officials use their
usual propaganda and lies to pretend that it was in fact a collision with a
foreign vessel and not the decrepitude of that – others were in the same
condition – warship which caused the catastrophe.
They try to
use the only resource they have for such an emergency, but it does not do the
job and the British and others offer immediate support – Colin firth is majestic
as Commodore David Russell.
Peter Simonischek
is another fabulous, sensational, phenomenal actor who has mesmerized, ravished
audiences with the recent, resplendent, one of the best films ever made – Toni Erdman.
He has the
role of Admiral Vyacheslav Grudzinky, who is in command of the fleet and the
submarine and when the disaster strikes, he is engaged in the effort to save
his men.
When all
that the Russian fleet has becomes useless – which it looks like it was to
begin with – he talks with Commodore Russell – the two had met each other
before the calamity.
Tragically,
his acceptance of the British support is not tolerated by his superiors who
demote him, stall the British when the loathsome Petrenko leads the talks and
they are concerned with their image and the idea that adversaries would steal
secrets from their ancient vessel.
The attitude
of the Russians - Putin in fact, for he is the Supreme Leader, the Tyrant who
gives the orders - is consistent, they have no qualms about using polonium on
one of their own – the late Litvinenko – or novichok, as in the recent
Salisbury attack, invade the Ukraine, meddle in elections in America – albeit their
puppet there, The stupid Donald denies it, for he believes the dictator and not
his own agencies – and elsewhere.
What are a
few sailors in this equation, where the Great Vladimir and his acolytes are
concerned with the Glory of Mother Russia?
Not much
indeed!
There is no
spoiler alert, for the end of this saga is known and it does detract from the
pleasure of trying to find what happens, although the details of the loathsome,
barbaric stand of those who should stand by their service men – there were no
women and there are none on their submarines, we can be sure of that, even if
it might be a state secret – and instead sentence them to die with monstrous
viciousness.
Niciun comentariu:
Trimiteți un comentariu