Timbuktu,
written and directed by Abderrahmane Sissako
Nine out of
10
The only Mauritanian
film we are ever likely to see – perhaps this cinephile should stop making
probability calculations for you and stick to his own chances – is indeed
phenomenal – it has been nominated for the most intrinsically valuable prize in
the cinematic world, the Palme d’Or at the 2014 Cannes film festival, the Oscar
and the BAFTA for Best Foreign Language Film and has won many other prizes,
including seven Césars.
The narrative
of the film is poignant, relevant in an age when we keep hearing about the jihadists
– the news of this very morning referred to the child of that estranged
teenager who has decided to join ISIS – and to my knowledge, she even brazenly
expressed a sort of later satisfaction with her gesture – and who has died, in
a camp where the ex- British mother is interned, with her citizenship revoked.
It helps a
Western understand better what happens on these frontlines, not the ones in the
relatively familiar – in a manner of speaking, for we keep seeing it in the
news – Afghanistan, Iraq, Yemen areas, but near Timbuktu, in Mali, where the
fundamentalists operate with almost total impunity – in spite of the fact that
there has been a French intervention and a push back against these forces of
evil.
The fundamentals
of the issue are exposed here, for we have characters that impose what they see
as sharia, with the exaggerations we know from Saudi Arabia – the country from
which teenagers have a tendency to try and run, when they can, finding themselves
in Hong Kong, Thailand, which kills and dismembers journalists, as in the most
recent case of the late Jamal Khashoggi – and abuse the population of the
village near Timbuktu, killing some people, including by stoning them to death!
Even music is
forbidden in the territories controlled by these mad men – going off on a
tangent here, we could look at the Trump country – much less murderous and less
insane of course – and think that at least, these people living in the Deseret lack
education – in case you vote for the Orange Lunatic, yours is not any good
anyway – and there are some extenuating circumstances, although joking in a Taliban
style, these would just be enough to ensure for a killer that does not know any
better, that he is executed in a more humane manner than he applies to his buried
in the ground victims.
Ibrahim Ahmed
is excellent in the role of Kidane, a cattle owner who lives with his wife,
Satima, in the desert, in a large tent, a man with a very gentle manner at
times, albeit involved in a fight in which another Malian is killed, seemingly
a devout Muslim that shows some of the other face of Islam.
Bill Maher tells
a joke about Islam being a religion of peace – there is a piece of you here, a
piece of you there – and the crazy fundamentalists that are present in this
formidable film belong to that dark, funeral side, imposing their terror,
banning laughter, cigarettes together with music, and enforcing arbitrarily the
rules from the Koran, whenever they choose.
In one such
situation, a man walks to the family of a very young teenager, long before she is
anyway near the marrying age, talks to her mother, saying that he saw her,
thinks she is fine and wants to marry her, but the parent is rather infuriated –
as she should be – by the proposal coming from a stranger – she says that she
thinks it absurd to give her young daughter away to someone she does not know.
Alas, this is
not the view of the barbaric tribunal – a group of vile, barbaric, monstrous men
that conduct the affairs of their community according to their perverted views
of the Muslim teachings - we can hear from moderates that this insistence on
violence is not the correct take on what is a peaceful religion – jokingly, we
have already established its credentials.
There is discussion
that goes to what seems the essence of the dispute within the Islamic communities
– besides, the others should take note perhaps and consider the fact that there
are lunatics, as is the case within any large enough group, religious or
otherwise, and sane, peaceful people – in which jihad seems to be explained with
its two opposing interpretations, one in which enraged, deranged men take up
arms to fight the generic infidels, while the other takes jihad to mean a fight
with self, in which we all need to be better, kinder...
Mehdi
Mohamed is probably better than the actor who has had to play Harry Potter,
albeit much less famous, and he has the role of Issan, the poor twelve year old
shepherd hired to care for the cattle of Kidane, which he takes to the water
one day, only to fall in a capital, tragic trap, when one of them – called GPS
for some reason, probably not in connection with the Global Positioning System,
which would have been a good, dark jest, given that this animal had a tendency
to be stubborn and lose her way – is moving into the nets of local man.
This individual
shouts, warning to some extent the helpless boy, but the latter has no means to
stop the cow from stepping into the fishing nets placed by the man who takes
his spear out, after a short interlude, targets the doomed animal and kills it
in front of a stunned audience – this viewer is almost one hundred per cent
sure that one or a few animals for the needed shots have been sacrificed to
render it possible, seeing the blood coming out of the nose of the body, the
closeness of the take and other elements of the shocking scene.
After this,
the shepherd returns to Kidane and tells him what happened, how one of just
eight cattle has gone – the fisherman could be understood to some degree –
especially if we consider his consequent fate – but he has exaggerated, could
have stepped into the water to face the cow, waited for a little longer, but
the issue is more complicated, for it has to do with pride, feeling of
ownership of that part of the water, retribution as necessary for status, to
prevent others from invading a cardinal territory, without which the family
would starve, traditions would need to be taken into account…
Kidane is out
to face the killer of one of his animals – without which there is no food for
his wife and daughter – with his gun and a fight ensues, with the two men
battling for their honor, families, existence, the habits of many generations, because
too much testosterone is involved, they have no support group there for
violence addicts, no analyst, little food and large areas covered with desert
where resources are scares and to survive means to fight.
The same
preposterous, fundamentalist tribunal will preside over a case in which they
demand for forty cattle to be paid – when Kidane only has seven left – and other
outrageous conditions.
Timbuktu is
an unforgettable, extraordinary motion picture.
Niciun comentariu:
Trimiteți un comentariu